Best Mascaras for Each Eyelash Type
Best mascaras for each eyelash type.
If you are anything like me, choosing mascara feels like choosing a soulmate. You want commitment. Loyalty. Zero flaking. Zero smudging. And preferably a formula that does not leave you looking like you cried during a Target run for no reason.
Over the years I’ve tried so many mascaras. Drugstore icons. High end divas. Waterproof warriors. Tubing formulas. Brown mascara for soft days. Even mascaras that people swear are the best mascara in the world, yet somehow my lashes disagree and revolt.
In this post I break down the best mascaras for each eyelash type. I’m sharing personal opinions, funny moments, fails, favorites, and tips that actually make a difference.
Get comfy. Get ready. Mascara talk is about to get deep.
This post contains affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.
Best Mascaras for Each Eyelash Type
Straight Lashes That Do Not Hold a Curl
If your lashes point forward or downward, this category is for you.
I have tried so many mascaras that promise curl, yet the second I walk outside, my lashes fall like they just gave up on life.
What works best: waterproof formulas and light tubing mascaras. They grip better and do not weigh down the curl.
My Top Picks
1. Maybelline Sky High Mascara Waterproof
This one has gone viral for a reason. The wand is flexible. The formula is lightweight. It holds curl like a champion. If you have straight lashes, I cannot recommend this enough. Plus it is drugstore, so you are not spending half your paycheck.
2. Lancôme Le 8 Hypnôse
This one surprised me. I used the Lancôme Cils Booster XL under it and wow. My lashes looked lifted and full but not crunchy. I would not use this alone on super straight lashes, but paired with the primer, it actually holds.
3. Tubing Mascara Options
Any good tubing mascara will resist humidity and keep lashes lifted. Tubing mascara creates little tubes around your lashes that stay put without weighing them down. A great option for straight lashes that want curl plus no smudging.
Short Lashes That Need Instant Length
Short lashes need a mascara that grabs every tiny hair. You want thin brushes. Spiky brushes. Precision.
My Top Picks
1. Maybelline Sky High Mascara
The thin wand is perfect for short lashes. Even the inner corner hairs that normally never participate suddenly pop up like they want attention.
2. KIKO Milano Twystable Mascara
This one is amazing for definition and length. KIKO mascaras are so underrated. The brush grabs tiny lashes easily. It makes lashes look longer without that heavy clumpy effect.
3. MAC Stack Mascara
This one adds length fast. It layers well. If you like dramatic length that builds, MAC Stack is for you. On short lashes it gives that spiky separated vibe.
Sparse or Thin Lashes That Need Fullness
If your lashes look light or you just do not have a lot of them, you need mascaras that add volume without clumps that make your lashes stick together.
My Top Picks
1. Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof
This mascara does not work on everyone, but on sparse lashes it gives instant fluff. The waterproof version keeps the curl and adds fullness. The wand is huge, so be patient if your eyes are small.
2. Lancôme Le 8 Hypnôse
This mascara has a thickening formula that coats lashes evenly. It makes lashes look richer, stronger, and fuller. I love pairing it with the Lancôme Cils Booster XL primer you showed. Primer makes a massive difference if your lashes are thin.
3. Brown Mascara Options
Hear me out. Brown mascara is amazing for sparse lashes because it makes them look fuller but softer. Black can sometimes highlight gaps. Brown fills in nicely and looks fluffy. Great for a soft no makeup makeup look.
Long Lashes That Need Definition Not Clumps
If you already have long lashes, your issue is usually clumping or smudging. You need clean formulas that separate.
My Top Picks
1. KIKO Milano Twystable
The separation on this one is stunning. If your lashes are already long, this will keep them looking clean and fanned out. An added bonus: you can twist the cap so so that it becomes a more “curled” brush!
2. Maybelline Sky High Mascara
Again. It is that good. It defines long lashes without making them stick together.
3. Any Tubing Mascara
Tubing mascara is perfect for long lashes that tend to smudge. The tubes stay in place and removal is super easy. No panda eyes.
Thick Lashes That Need Control Not Clumps
Thick lashes can look messy fast. You need mascara that defines, separates, and keeps the hairs in line.
My Top Picks
1. MAC Stack Mascara
This mascara is amazing on thick lashes because it layers well without becoming chunky. You can build as much volume as you want.
2. Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
Thick lashes can handle this formula. The dramatic wand works in your favor.
3. Mascara Maybelline Classic Great Lash
Simple. Clean. Iconic. It separates and controls thick lashes really well.
Lashes That Smudge with Every Mascara
If you always get mascara under your eyes, do not blame your lashes. Usually smudging happens because:
You use rich eye cream.
Your under eyes get oily.
Your mascara is not waterproof.
Your formula is too creamy.
Smudging is one of my biggest mascara struggles. I have cried mascara tears more times than I want to admit.
What Works Best
1. Tubing Mascara
Tubing mascara changed my life. It never smudges. It stays on until you remove it with warm water. Perfect for oily skin or humid weather.
2. Waterproof Mascara Maybelline Options
Maybelline waterproof formulas are some of the best in the drugstore. Sky High waterproof and Lash Sensational waterproof are unbeatable for smudge control.
3. Brown Mascara
Brown mascara smudges less because the formula is often lighter. Plus, even if tiny smudges happen, they look softer.
Lashes That Need Drama and Volume for Nights Out
Sometimes you want your lashes to walk into the room before you do.
You want thickness. Boldness. Intensity.
My Top Pick
Lancôme Le 8 Hypnôse
Elegant drama. Full but not messy.
Lashes That Need Soft Natural Everyday Look
Sometimes you just want pretty lashes without doing the most.
My Top Pick
Brown Mascara
Soft. Pretty. Natural. Makes you look awake but not overdone. Perfect for work or school days.
My Personal Experiences and Thoughts
Here is my honest experience with each mascara.
MAC Stack
Amazing volume and length. Builds really well. Does not flake on me. The wand is very good for grabbing tiny lashes.
Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof
So dramatic. I love the waterproof version much more than the regular. The regular one smudges on me. The waterproof holds curl beautifully.
KIKO Twystable
Super underrated. Clean. Lengthening. Great separation.
Maybelline Sky High Mascara
One word. Success.
This mascara works on almost everyone. Length. Curl. Zero clumps. Perfect wand.
Lancôme Le 8 Hypnôse + Cils Booster XL
Using both together makes lashes look like a dream. It feels luxurious. Soft but dramatic. Zero heaviness.
Mascara Tips That Actually Work
Here are tips that make a real difference:
Curl your lashes before applying mascara.
Use a lash primer if your lashes are sparse.
Wiggle the wand at the base for maximum volume.
Apply mascara to the back of your lashes for extra lift.
For lower lashes use minimal product.
For smudge free days choose tubing mascaras.
For work or natural days choose brown mascara.
Replace mascara every three months for hygiene.
FAQ
What is the best mascara for straight lashes?
Sky High Mascara Waterproof is one of the best picks. It holds curl and adds length.
What is tubing mascara?
Tubing mascara wraps each lash in tiny tubes instead of coating them. It is smudge proof and removes with warm water.
Is brown mascara worth it?
Yes. Brown mascara is soft, natural, and great for daytime looks or sparse lashes.
Is mascara Maybelline good?
Yes. Maybelline makes some of the best mascara formulas at the drugstore. Sky High, Lash Sensational, and Great Lash are classics.
Why does my mascara smudge?
Usually because of oils around the eyes. Switch to waterproof or tubing formulas.
How do I choose the best mascara for my eyelash type?
Figure out your lash needs. If your lashes are straight choose waterproof. If they are sparse choose thickening. If they smudge choose tubing.
Outro
Best mascaras for each eyelash type is a topic I could talk about for hours because mascara truly transforms a look. Once you find the right one your whole routine becomes easier.
This post shared the best mascaras for each eyelash type, along with real tips, personal experiences, and everything you need to choose the best mascara for you.
This post showed you the best mascaras for each eyelash type, you may also like:
