Best Lush Product Ideas Worth Rebuying (And a Few I Wouldn’t)
If you’ve ever stood in a Lush store surrounded by all those colorful, fragrant handmade goodies thinking, “Where do I even start?”, same.
Over the years, I’ve tried a bunch of Lush products and have built a pretty solid stash. Some I’d rebuy in a heartbeat. Others? Not so much.
This post is your inside look at which lush product ideas are really worth the hype, and your money, based on my own experience.
If you’re into body care, unique scents, or want to make your first purchase from Lush without wasting a dime, you’re in the right place.
Lush Product Ideas Worth Rebuying
Let the Good Times Roll Body Spray
Let me start strong. This spray is a full-on vibe.
It smells like warm caramel popcorn with a splash of cozy vanilla. Comforting, sweet, and kind of nostalgic. It’s the same scent as the cult-favorite cleanser but in a mist.
I spray it on my clothes, sheets, even in the bathroom after a shower. It’s that good. Lasts long too.
If you’re into happy soap vibes, this one brings all the joy.
Let the Good Times Roll Body Lotion
Not to be dramatic, but I’d bathe in this if I could.
Thick, buttery texture. Melts into your skin. And the scent? Warm, sweet, just like the spray. Together, they make you smell like a walking bakery in the best way.
This lotion gives major positive impact on dry skin days. Definitely one of my top rebuy picks.
Soft Coeur Massage Bar
This one lives in one of my trusty Lush tins.
Smells like chocolate and honey. Literally melts into your skin. Super softening and perfect for date night or pampering yourself after a long bath.
Warning though: it can get messy in summer, so keep it in a cool place.
Still, it’s rich, indulgent, and honestly one of the best body care treats they make.
Full of Grace Facial Bar
The other tin holds this little skincare gem.
It’s a solid serum, perfect for calming irritated or dry skin. I use it at night when I want my face to drink up something healing.
No heavy scent, just earthy and light. And it works.
Definitely rebuying this, especially for winter skin emergencies.
Yog Nog Body Wash
This is dessert in a bottle.
It smells like caramel, butter cookies, and a cozy holiday market. But not in an overwhelming way. It’s creamy, nourishing, and makes showering feel like a treat.
I use this when I want to feel wrapped in a sweet hug. It’s limited edition, so I hoard it when it’s back.
A huge yes for anyone who likes new scent experiences that feel festive.
Happy Hippy Body Wash
This is my go-to for those mornings when I need a slap of citrus to wake up.
It smells like grapefruit, clean, fresh, and juicy. No frills, just good energy in a bottle.
Perfect summer body wash and one of their most travel size-friendly scents.
The Olive Branch Body Wash
This one surprised me.
It’s more unisex, earthy, and herbal than most Lush scents. If Happy Hippy is sunrise in Capri, The Olive Branch is chilling under an orange tree in Tuscany.
Moisturizing. Subtle. Mature. If you’re not into sweet, try this.
Sunrise Body Wash
This one smells… like a tropical drink with citrus on the rim. Bright, sweet, a little zesty.
It’s good for waking up your senses, and the formula is gentle too.
I rotate this one with Happy Hippy, especially during warmer months. Would absolutely repurchase.
Sparkling Light Body Wash
Glowy skin in a bottle.
This one has a soft, creamy feel with a light shimmer and a gentle citrus-vanilla scent.
Not glittery, just radiant. It leaves your skin smelling fresh but not overly perfumed.
Perfect before a night out or when I want to feel a little extra.
Aqua Marina Fresh Cleanser
Weird texture. Weird smell. Great results.
This cleanser is pink, wrapped in seaweed, and smells… well, earthy. But it’s calming, soothing, and leaves my skin soft and clean.
When I’m feeling dry or red, this is what I use. Great for sensitive skin and definitely a conscious beauty pick.
Ultrabland Makeup Remover
This is a holy grail product if you wear makeup, especially stubborn mascara.
It’s thick, creamy, unscented, and works like magic. You rub it on dry skin, wipe it off with a damp cloth, and your skin feels hydrated and clean.
No burning, no irritation. Great for luxury skin care fans looking for simplicity.
Rub Rub Rub Body Exfoliator
This one’s bold.
It’s a scrubby, sea-salty, floral-scented powerhouse. I use it before shaving or when I want my skin to feel like silk.
It lathers up too, so you can use it as a shower gel and scrub in one.
Downside? You’ll run out fast. But it’s so worth it.
Sakura Shower Gel
This one is floral, airy, and gentle. Very spring-like.
If you don’t love sweet or citrusy scents, Sakura is a great choice. It’s subtle, clean, and refreshing without being basic.
I use it when I want something light and simple. A solid everyday body wash.
Fairly Traded Honey Shampoo
This shampoo is underrated.
It’s incredibly moisturizing and smells like actual honey. A little goes a long way, and it leaves your hair shiny and soft without weighing it down.
Best for dry or frizz-prone hair. Plus, it supports ethical sourcing, so feel-good purchase all around.
Lush Lemony Flutter: Why I Love This Cuticle Butter
Lemony Flutter is one of those classic Lush products that keeps its cult status for a reason. It’s marketed as a cuticle butter, but honestly, it’s so much more than that.
The texture is thick and buttery, packed with nourishing ingredients like shea butter, mango butter, lemon oil, and avocado oil. The scent is bright and citrusy, almost like a freshly zested lemon, which makes it feel uplifting every time I open the little pot.
Why I love it? First, a tiny bit goes a long way. I’ve had one pot last months, even with daily use. Second, it’s multipurpose. Sure, it softens cuticles beautifully, but I also use it on dry elbows, heels, and even those rough patches on my hands that show up in winter. It sinks in slowly, so I like to apply it at night and wake up with soft, hydrated skin. PS: Alex Consani loves it too, and she showed it in the What’s in My Bag iconic video, and I get it.
Products I Wouldn’t Rebuy
Super Milk
I wanted to like this. The formula is good. Really good.
It detangles, hydrates, and preps hair perfectly.
But the scent? Way too sweet and vanilla-heavy for me.
If you’re a vanilla scent lover, this might be your jam. I just couldn’t get into it.
Sticky Dates Shower Gel
This one is sweet to the extreme.
It smells like brown sugar and syrup, and the scent sticks. Some people adore it, but for me it felt too much. Like bathing in dessert.
Not a bad product, just not for my nose.
5 More Lush Product Ideas You’ll Want to Rebuy
If you’re anything like me, once you start using Lush products, there’s no going back.
And guess what?
I’ve added five more gems to my rebuy list, this time a mix of scents and lip saviors. These are products that have truly earned their place in my everyday rotation.
Here’s the lowdown:
Lip Service Balm
Texture: Light and citrusy
Best for: Dry, chapped lips that need a little zing
Why I’d rebuy: It’s basically a lip spa in a tin.
Let’s talk about underrated Lush heroes, Lip Service doesn’t get enough love. This one is citrusy, smooth, and actually stays on your lips longer than most natural balms. It doesn’t just coat, it heals. I keep this one in my bag for those no-makeup days when I still want to feel somewhat alive.
Tip: Works great over matte lipstick if you’re feeling wild.
Honey Trap Balm
Texture: Creamy, buttery, slightly minty
Best for: Anyone who wants soft lips that smell like dessert
Why I’d rebuy: This is a comfort balm. Period.
If Lip Service is my daytime buddy, Honey Trap is my night balm. The name is accurate, it’s got this creamy honey-mint combo that’s straight-up addictive. You don’t even need much. One little swipe and your lips feel like velvet.
Personal thought: This one makes you want to kiss yourself. I said what I said.
American Cream Perfume (Liquid & Solid)
Scent profile: Vanilla milkshake with a nostalgic twist
Best for: When you want to feel cozy, sexy, and 90s all at once
Why I’d rebuy: I literally own it in two formats.
I’m a vanilla girl, but I’m picky. American Cream hits that perfect balance between sweet and wearable. It’s creamy but not cloying, comforting but not dull. The spray version is great for mornings, while the solid perfume is perfect for touch-ups or tossing in a tiny purse.
Bonus: People will ask what you’re wearing. Every. Time.
Goodnight Sweetheart Perfume
Scent profile: Lavender, chamomile, soft bedtime vibes
Best for: Evenings, post-shower, winding down
Why I’d rebuy: It makes me feel like I’m the main character of a lullaby.
This scent is so gentle and dreamy. If you’re into calming, herbal fragrances that feel like a hug in scent form, Goodnight Sweetheart is for you. It has this subtle lavender-meets-vanilla softness that lingers on your skin in the best way.
Nighttime ritual tip: Pair it with chamomile tea and a warm blanket. Instant peace.
Lush Product Comparison Table
Lush Product Rebought Ideas
| Product | Type | Scent Profile | Would I Rebuy? | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Let the Good Times Roll | Body Spray/Lotion | Sweet, caramel corn | ✅ Yes | Cozy, unique, great for layering |
| Soft Coeur | Massage Bar | Cocoa + honey | ✅ Yes | Indulgent and softening |
| Full of Grace | Face Bar | Herbal, light | ✅ Yes | Great for calming skin |
| Yog Nog | Body Wash | Sweet, creamy, festive | ✅ Yes | Best for winter vibes |
| Happy Hippy | Body Wash | Grapefruit, fresh | ✅ Yes | Energizing and light |
| The Olive Branch | Body Wash | Herbal, earthy | ✅ Yes | Unique and moisturizing |
| Sunrise | Body Wash | Citrus, tropical | ✅ Yes | Bright and juicy |
| Sparkling Light | Body Wash | Vanilla-citrus, light | ✅ Yes | Glowy skin and soft scent |
| Aqua Marina | Cleanser | Earthy, marine | ✅ Yes | Calming for sensitive skin |
| Ultrabland | Makeup Remover | Neutral | ✅ Yes | Effective and gentle |
| Rub Rub Rub | Body Exfoliator | Floral, salty | ✅ Yes | Scrubby and satisfying |
| Sakura | Body Wash | Soft floral | ✅ Yes | Light and airy |
| Fairly Traded Honey | Shampoo | Real honey | ✅ Yes | Moisturizing and natural |
| Super Milk | Hair Primer | Strong vanilla | ❌ No | Great formula, not my scent |
| Sticky Dates | Body Wash | Syrupy sweet | ❌ No | Overwhelming fragrance |
| Lip Service | Lip Balm | Citrusy, clean | ✅ Yes | Lightweight and healing |
| Honey Trap | Lip Balm | Creamy honey + mint | ✅ Yes | Comforting and nourishing |
| American Cream (Perfume) | Liquid Perfume | Creamy vanilla | ✅ Yes | Cozy, nostalgic scent |
| American Cream (Solid) | Solid Perfume | Creamy vanilla | ✅ Yes | Perfect for travel |
| Goodnight Sweetheart | Perfume | Herbal lavender | ✅ Yes | Calming and bedtime-ready |
FAQ
Are Lush products good for sensitive skin?
Yes, many are. Try Full of Grace, Ultrabland, or Aqua Marina.
Do Lush shower gels expire quickly?
They’re fresh, so yes, but if stored well, they last months.
Are these products vegan?
Some are, but not all (like the Honey shampoo). Lush labels everything clearly.
Can I recycle the bottles?
Yes. Bring five empty containers back to the store and get a free face mask.
Which product is best for gifting?
Soft Coeur or Yog Nog, they’re crowd-pleasers.
Final Thoughts
When it comes to lush product ideas worth rebuying, a few always rise to the top.
Let the Good Times Roll? Staple.
Full of Grace? Skincare savior.
Soft Coeur? Forever in my tin.
Others like Sticky Dates or Super Milk didn’t work for me, but that’s the beauty of handmade cosmetics. There’s something for every nose and skin type.
This post showed you my honest picks for the best Lush product ideas worth rebuying. You may also like:
